Kanidm vs Keycloak
| Attribute | Kanidm | Keycloak |
|---|---|---|
| Protocols | OAuth2 and OpenID Connect; read-only LDAPS gateway; RADIUS | OpenID Connect, OAuth 2.0, and SAML |
| Machines and networks | SSH key distribution, Linux and Unix login, RADIUS for VPNs | SSH keys, RADIUS, and Linux login are not on its feature list |
| Existing directories | Acts as the directory, with a read-only LDAPS gateway | Connects to existing LDAP or Active Directory servers |
| License | MPL-2.0 | Apache-2.0 |
| Purpose | An identity management server with user accounts, groups, and authentication policies. | Single sign-on and user federation for applications. |
| Documented capabilities | User accounts, Group management, Authentication policies | Single sign-on, OIDC and SAML, User federation |
| Best-fit workflow | An identity management server with user accounts, groups, and authentication policies. | Platform teams putting one login in front of several applications. |
| Check before choosing | Check current installation requirements and edition limits in the linked repository. | Keycloak is an identity system, not a drop-in widget. Plan themes, realms, and upgrades. |
| Deployment options | See repository installation guide | Docker, Kubernetes |
| GitHub stars | 5,582 | 37,972 |
| License | MPL-2.0 | Apache-2.0 |
| Self-hosted | Yes | Yes |
| Docker noted | Not recorded | Yes |
| Cloud / hosted | Not recorded | Not recorded |
| Primary language | Rust | Java |
| Last commit | 2026-11-19 | 2026-11-19 |
| Difficulty | Not assessed | Advanced |
| Content source | Editorial catalog entry | Editorial catalog entry |
| Metadata checked | 2026-11-20 | 2026-11-20 |
| Forks | 368 | 9.2k |
| Star growth | +143 (2026-10-04 to 2026-11-20) | +894 (2026-10-01 to 2026-11-20) |
| Alternative to | Not recorded | Auth0, Okta |
This comparison uses recorded capabilities, not hands-on performance tests. A capability missing from one record does not mean that product lacks it. Confirm edition, version and current pricing in the official documentation.
Kanidm or Keycloak?
Pick Kanidm when you want one identity platform for people and Linux machines: it is an OAuth2 and OpenID Connect provider with passkey (WebAuthn) authentication, a read-only LDAPS gateway for older systems, RADIUS for network and VPN logins, SSH key distribution, and Linux and Unix login with TPM-protected offline authentication. It is MPL-2.0 licensed.
Pick Keycloak when your applications need SAML, which is not on Kanidm's feature list (an open issue in its repository discusses adding it), or when you want to federate users from an existing LDAP or Active Directory server and broker logins from social and other identity providers. It is Apache-2.0 licensed and a Cloud Native Computing Foundation incubation project.
When to consider Kanidm
An identity management server with user accounts, groups, and authentication policies.
Check current installation requirements and edition limits in the linked repository.
Kanidm documentation and sourceWhen to consider Keycloak
Platform teams putting one login in front of several applications.
Keycloak is an identity system, not a drop-in widget. Plan themes, realms, and upgrades.
Keycloak documentation and sourceKanidm vs Keycloak questions
- What is Kanidm?
- An identity management server with user accounts, groups, and authentication policies.
- What is Keycloak?
- Single sign-on and user federation for applications.
- Can you self-host Kanidm and Keycloak?
- Both can be self-hosted.
- What licenses do Kanidm and Keycloak use?
- Kanidm uses the MPL-2.0 license. Keycloak uses the Apache-2.0 license.
- Which has more GitHub stars, Kanidm or Keycloak?
- Keycloak has 38k stars and Kanidm has 5.6k. Stars show attention; check recent commits and releases for maintenance.
- What languages are Kanidm and Keycloak written in?
- Kanidm is mainly written in Rust. Keycloak is mainly written in Java.